Tri-Wellness
  • Home
  • About
    • Lisa Shanken
    • Brooke Null
  • Wellness Services
    • Personal Wellness Services
    • Festival Wellness Services
  • Executive Function Coaching
  • Blog
  • Contact

Schedule An Appointment

Tri-Wellness

Tri-Wellness

The Best Online Executive Functioning Coach

Schedule An Appointment

  • Home
  • About
    • Lisa Shanken
    • Brooke Null
  • Wellness Services
    • Personal Wellness Services
    • Festival Wellness Services
  • Executive Function Coaching
  • Blog
  • Contact

The South Beach Diet: Sounds Compelling – But Does It Work?

By Lisa Shanken
July 8, 2010
The South Beach Diet is expensive to follow.

Despite how popular the South Beach Diet is, I would never recommend it to any of my clients who come in for nutrition consultations. In this article, I've compiled research on why the South Beach Diet is not a replacement for a healthy diet.

The South Beach Diet was developed by cardiologist Dr. Agatston in the 1980s as a strategy to help his patients reduce their risk of heart attack. The diet is based on the idea that good carbohydrates are those that score low on the glycemic index[2] and that the dieter could consequently 'kill' the hunger pangs that accompany high sugar intake. Though some of Dr. Agatston's ideology is sound, like introducing oily fish and nuts, the extreme phases of the diet, i.e. lack of solid exercise and lack of evidence-based research make this diet a poor choice overall.

First of all, no long term studies have been conducted on the South Beach Diet. The 2005 study[3] by Kraft Foods showed favorable results, but the study only lasted 3 months. The longest study, done over one year, was conducted by Agatston[3], the same man who created the diet, so I'd like to take his results with a grain of salt since there hasn't been enough broad testing within the general public who followed the diet themselves.

Secondly, the diet is simply too "one-size-fits-all." The nutritional needs of men and women vary greatly, not to mention the nutritional needs of small versus large people, economically capable people versus budget-conscious people and active people versus inactive people. To group such a diverse community of people into one category and asking them to follow the same diet plan can only result in an awkward application of those principles. This is highlighted by the fact that the South Beach Diet, a significant component of which involves dairy intake, doesn't cater to the lactose intolerant[2], which comprises 4-7 percent of the world's population. Finally, the South Beach Diet lacks control, allowing food such as french fries and a lack of exercise. The end product? A weak, slightly slimmer person who may not remain so as the months progress.

The South Beach Diet also fills dieters with false hope. It makes the tragic mistake of telling dieters that most of the weight will be shed from their midsection[1], when in fact the weight loss in the first two weeks is a result of the water released from your body from the lack of carbs. The first phase of eliminating almost all cards is so unrealistic that many people I know who have tried the South Beach Diet have given up in sheer frustration.

I also have budget concerns about dieters who practice the South Beach Diet. In order to fulfill the fish requirements alone, the average person would have to spend a lot more as well as cook the meals themselves, making this diet painfully unrealistic for the working person. In an article "Can only the rich afford to be thin?" written by USA Today[4] it was calculated that following the South Beach Diet's exorbitant menu would cost $90 a week. In the same article, Adam Drewnowski[4], director of the Center for Public Health Nutrition at the University of Washington-Seattle notes, "To suggest to the lower middle class or poor that they eat a diet filled with foods like red snapper, radicchio, fresh tomatoes, baby lamb chops, olive oil and merlot wine is blatant economic elitism."

Was this helpful? Let me know by leaving a comment below.

References:

[1] South Beach Diet by Mayo Clinic Staff

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/south-beach-diet/MY00499

[2] South Beach Diet 101: South Beach Diet Pros and Cons

http://www.south-beach-diet-101.com/learn/south-beach-diet-pros-cons.html

[3] Wikipedia: South Beach Diet

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Beach_Diet

[4] Can only the rich afford to be thin? (USA Today)

http://www.usatoday.com/life/lifestyle/2004-05-02-diet-cover_x.htm

Share this article
Previous Post
<
Next Post
>
profile-image

Lisa Shanken

My passion is to help you live your healthiest and most harmonious life, but in a way that’s realistic and practical for you as a unique individual on this planet. My philosophy is all about “balance,” never a diet since a diet is not sustainable for life, aka Kill The Diet.

Related Posts
Supporting Things Close To Your Heart

Supporting Things Close To Your Heart

By Lisa Shanken
February 24, 2023
Happy February (and almost the end of winter!). This month I was lucky enough to be part of the Wellness At Sea program on Jam Cruise, a very special 6 night music festival at sea. Many of you know that some of my greatest passions in life include wellness and...
Read Article
Gluten Free

How to Easily Transition To A Gluten Free Diet

By Lisa Shanken
January 24, 2023
Switching to a gluten free diet has been pretty trendy over the past few years (especially if you reside in my hometown of Boulder, CO), but for good reason! Celiac Disease, which is an autoimmune disease causing an allergy to wheat, is one reason people may be forced to go...
Read Article
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 82
  • Go to Next Page »

Testimonials

Lisa’s weight loss plan really gave me a new insight to healthy eating and living. I was diagnosed with breast cancer in January 2015. Healthy living/easting/exercise has become very important to me and my family and this program really helped me get even more on the course with this and helped me lose weight.

Danielle D, Great Neck, NY

When I heard about the 10 Day Weight Loss Challenge, I wasn’t sure if it would be a good fit, since as a physician, I understand nutrition and health (and therefore knew the dangers of fad diets, etc…), and I do my best to exercise (though not always enough). But as a single mother of 2, it’s still very challenging ti “fit in all in” (including cooking healthy meals for my children) due to my busy schedule. And when my time is short, bad habits crop up and weight gain follows.

Dr. Gila Ackerman, Boulder, CO

Psychiatrist
Lisa has made an enormous contribution to my health and strength. I have seen and felt the most fantastic changes in an amazingly short time.

Chessie F, Boulder, CO

I just wanted to say you were amazing through this 10 day process! I learned so much from you! You were very thorough in all areas of the challenge and got back to us in such a quick manner with our questions. It was a great jump start into a more healthy life style that’s for sure!

Colby E, Boulder, Colorado

I LOVE the recipes, simple, few ingredients, appealing. I like the idea of using the list of staples you provided when i was tempted to cheat!

Phyliss S, Spring House, PA

I worked with Lisa to develop a holistic wellness plan that has allowed personal growth without having to completely change my lifestyle. Her programs are designed around your personal needs, so I always feel like I've gotten the most from my sessions and leave with manageable goals. Lisa's three-prong approach to wellness (fitness, nutrition and health) is helping me live a balanced and grateful life.

Ali S., Boulder, CO

I’ve been through the ringer with different dieting plans through the years. Some helped me lose weight and some didn’t – but it didn’t matter because I would always gain it back. I didn’t know if this 10 day Weight Loss Challenge would be the answer since everyone says they have the “BEST” way to lose weight. But this one seemed to be more doable – like instead of starving myself, keeping track of calories (“been there done that – VERY annoying!”) and things I know I wouldn’t stick to.

Jill W, Park, NY

Lisa, you have been a very positive role model for me! Through the exercise and diet I’m becoming healthy and more positive about my life!!! Thanks!

Melissa B, Boulder, Colorado

Blog Articles

Supporting Things Close To Your Heart

Supporting Things Close To Your Heart

Read More »
Gluten Free

How to Easily Transition To A Gluten Free Diet

Read More »
Happy Holidays

Healthy Holiday Cooking Tips – 2022

Read More »
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 55
  • Go to Next Page »

Send Us A Message

Footer

triw-logo-link2-with-URL-e1576220504179-1@2x-min

Quick Links

  • About
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Member’s Area
  • Contact

Services

  • Personal Wellness Services
  • Festival Wellness Services
  • Executive Function Coaching

Newsletter Signup

Get the latest wellness, nutrition, fitness, and 
mental health tips and news from Tri-Wellness 
delivered straight to your inbox.
Subscribe Now

Copyright 2022. Lisa Shanken. All Rights Reserved
Designed and Developed by Gloss

  • Disclosure Policy
  • Medical Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service